Guides

SumUp Loyalty vs Square Loyalty: Which Suits a Small Shop?

By , founder of Stridec · Updated

In short SumUp Loyalty (SumUp Connect) lists plans from US$199 to US$349 a month on its pricing page, read 15 November 2026, with no free plan. Square's loyalty page returned an HTTP 429 error when we tried to read it that day, so we state no Square price or rule and suggest you confirm them with Square. A small shop that wants only spend, earn and redeem should also price a points-only programme such as Gimify, which is free for one outlet.

How it works in Gimify: the customer shows the QR on their phone, staff key in the bill on the counter tablet, and points land straight away. No app for the customer to download.

Which is better, SumUp Loyalty or Square Loyalty?

Both come from payments companies that also sell a till and card readers. SumUp’s loyalty product is called SumUp Connect. Square’s is Square Loyalty. For most owners the deciding fact is which till and reader you run today, followed by the monthly price at your number of outlets.

We tried to read both vendors’ pages on 15 November 2026. SumUp’s pages opened and we recorded what they state. Square’s loyalty page and pricing page both returned an HTTP 429 error (too many requests), so we recorded nothing from them and state no Square price, earning rule or tier. Where a page showed no figure, we left it out. Pages change, so read each vendor’s page before you buy.

What does the SumUp page say?

SumUp’s loyalty overview describes Connect as “an always-on marketing and customer loyalty tool”. The pages we read list these features by name:

  • AutoPilot messaging and AI-enhanced messages
  • A customer database that tracks activity with every transaction
  • Loyalty and rewards
  • Customer acquisition, performance insights and review boost

The pricing page lists four monthly prices.

PlanPrice shownWhat the page says it includes
Connect PlusUS$269 a monthCustomer Directory, AutoPilot messaging, 2 standard promos a month
Connect ProUS$349 a monthEverything in Plus, plus unlimited AI-enhanced messaging, review boost and text-to-join
POS with Connect PlusUS$199 a monthCloud-based POS, customer rewards, automated marketing, 2 monthly promotions, weekly SMS and email promotions
POS with Connect ProUS$289 a monthCloud-based POS, customer rewards, automated marketing, unlimited marketing promotions, unlimited SMS and email promotions

Source: SumUp Connect pricing and SumUp Connect overview, read 15 November 2026. Neither page shows a date. The text we retrieved placed each price above its plan name, so the pairing is our reading of the layout.

The same page says “No hidden fees. No surprise charges. No complicated contracts.” It mentions a Money Back Guarantee, marked with an asterisk, and we did not find its terms. It shows no contract length, setup fee or free plan.

What can we say about Square Loyalty?

Very little from our own read, and we would rather say so than guess. Square’s loyalty page returned HTTP 429 when we requested it on 15 November 2026, and so did its pricing page. A second attempt a few seconds later gave the same result.

Here is what to check on Square’s own pages before you compare:

QuestionWhere to look
Is there a plan price, or only a free trial?Square Loyalty
How are points earned: by visit, by amount or by item?Same page
Does it include tiers, bonus promotions or texts?Same page
Can customers earn on cash sales?Same page
Does it work without Square’s point of sale?Same page, or ask Square

Our Square Loyalty alternatives guide records what an earlier read of Square’s page showed, and our Square Loyalty vs Toast Loyalty comparison sets Square against its closest restaurant rival.

Which one suits a small shop?

Match the tool to the till and to the rules you will use.

  1. You run SumUp readers or SumUp POS. SumUp Connect is the natural first look. The bundle prices are lower than the standalone ones on the same page. Check whether you would pay for messaging features you will not use.
  2. You run Square. Square Loyalty is the natural first look. Get its price in writing, since we could not read it.
  3. You run neither, or outlets on different systems. Neither built-in tool is aimed at you. SumUp says Connect works with several POS systems without listing them, so ask.
  4. You plan to change your till. A loyalty programme tied to the till has to be rebuilt and members join again. See how to switch loyalty apps for a short overlap plan.

Do you need messaging, promotions and a customer database?

SumUp’s plans are built around them. The monthly price rises with the number of promotions and the amount of messaging. Each one is a rule to run and a message to write, and the price tells you the vendor sees them as the product.

If you send a promotion every week and can name the visits it brings, that money works for you. If you do not, you pay for features that sit unused. A first test is cheaper: sign customers up, award points on each sale and see whether members return. Our loyalty program cost guide shows what the options cost at different sizes.

What is the points-only view?

Our view is that the simplest programme wins, because every customer already understands spend, earn and redeem. Promotions, bonus multipliers and tiers add things a customer has to learn. That is a position, and the research on it is mixed. Our case for points-only loyalty sets out the evidence and where it is thin.

Applied here, both vendors can offer rewards, but SumUp’s own price table is organised around marketing extras. You give things up with a points-only tool. You get no built-in tiers, no scheduled promotions and no SMS or email campaigns. If you rely on those, a points-only tool will not replace them.

Where does Gimify fit?

Gimify is a hosted, points-only programme that works with whichever till you run, so it does not depend on SumUp or Square hardware. Customers scan a QR code and enter their email, with no app download, and the member card can be saved to Google Wallet. Staff add or redeem points on any phone at the counter, and one points balance works across every outlet. It is free for one outlet with unlimited members, and US$99 a month covers unlimited outlets with no per-member or per-location fees. You can start free and run it beside your current till.

Questions owners ask

Is SumUp Loyalty or Square Loyalty better for a small shop?

Neither wins in general. Each is sold by a payments company that also sells a till, so the likelier fit is the one that matches the till and card reader you already use. Compare a written price for your own number of outlets before you decide.

How much does SumUp Loyalty cost?

SumUp's pricing page, read 15 November 2026, lists Connect Plus at US$269 a month and Connect Pro at US$349 a month. With SumUp POS it lists US$199 and US$289 a month. It shows no free plan.

How much does Square Loyalty cost?

We cannot say. Square's loyalty page returned an HTTP 429 error when we tried to read it on 15 November 2026, so we recorded no price. Ask Square for a written quote for your location.

Do I need SumUp POS to use SumUp Loyalty?

SumUp's pricing page says Connect is designed to integrate with several POS systems, but especially the SumUp POS. It does not list which systems. Ask SumUp whether your current till is supported.

Does SumUp Loyalty send texts and emails?

SumUp's pricing page lists AutoPilot messaging, and the POS bundles list weekly or unlimited SMS and email promotions. Messaging is part of what you pay for, so ask how it is limited on the plan you pick.

What if I want plain points without either vendor's extras?

A standalone points programme works at any counter. Gimify is hosted, points-only and free for one outlet, and staff add points on any phone.

Read next

Start free

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.

Start free See plans