Square Loyalty vs Toast Loyalty: Which Suits a Small Shop?
By Alva Chew, founder of Stridec · Updated
In short Square Loyalty vs Toast Loyalty mostly comes down to which till you already run, because each is built into its own point of sale. On the pages we read on 15 November 2026, Square offers a 30-day free trial and Toast shows a See Pricing button, and neither shows a plan price. Both go beyond plain points, so a small shop that wants only spend, earn and redeem should also price a points-only programme such as Gimify, which is free for one outlet.
Which is better, Square Loyalty or Toast Loyalty?
Both are loyalty tools that sit inside a point of sale. Square Loyalty comes with Square’s payments and POS. Toast Loyalty comes with Toast, a restaurant POS. For most owners the deciding fact is simple: which till do you run today? If you run Square, Toast Loyalty is not really an option, and if you run Toast, the reverse is true.
The harder question is whether either suits a small shop that mainly wants regulars to come back. Both offer more than plain points, and neither showed a plan price on the pages we read.
We opened Square’s and Toast’s pages on 15 November 2026 and recorded only what they state. Where a page showed no figure, we left it out. Pages change, so read each vendor’s page before you buy.
How do Square Loyalty and Toast Loyalty compare side by side?
| Item | Square Loyalty | Toast Loyalty |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | Square payments and POS users | “Restaurants using the Toast POS platform” |
| Price shown | None. “Try Square Loyalty free for 30 days” | None. A “See Pricing” button |
| Earning | Points by visits, amount spent, or items and categories | Points by dollars spent or visits made |
| Tiers | VIP tiers: Bronze 1.5x, Silver 2x, Gold 3x | Tiered cash rewards in the support FAQ |
| Bonuses | Limited-time or recurring bonus-point promotions | Time-based and order-type bonuses, welcome bonuses, birthday treats |
| Messaging | Transactional texts when points or rewards are earned | Loyalty emails and SMS notifications in the support FAQ |
| Sign-up | At the point of sale, on a Square website or through an invoice | At the register, digital receipt, online ordering or a sign-up link |
Sources: Square Loyalty, Toast Loyalty and Toast Loyalty FAQ, read 15 November 2026. The Toast FAQ page is dated 19 October 2026 on the page.
Our own re-check of both pages later that day was blocked by the vendors’ sites (an HTTP 429 from Square and a 403 from Toast), so the table reflects the earlier read the same day. Treat any detail you rely on as something to confirm with the vendor.
What does each one cost?
We could not find a price for either, and we state none.
| Vendor | What the page showed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Square | 30-day free trial, no plan price on the loyalty page | Square Loyalty, 15 November 2026 |
| Toast | “See Pricing” on the loyalty page. Pricing page shows “Flexible pricing options” and Contact Sales, with no loyalty price in the text we read | Toast pricing, footer dated 20 August 2026 |
| Toast footnote | “Pricing applies to new customers and single locations only” | Same Toast pricing page |
A free trial is not a price. Ask each vendor for a written quote that names the loyalty module, the cost per location and any fee tied to messages. Then compare the same number of outlets. Our Square Loyalty alternatives and Toast Loyalty alternatives pages list options that do publish prices.
Which one suits a small shop?
Match the tool to the till and to the rules you will actually use.
- You run Square and sell across a counter, a stall or a small shop. Square Loyalty is the natural first look. Its cash-sale rule helps if some customers pay cash. Check the price for your country and location.
- You run Toast in a restaurant. Toast Loyalty ties into online ordering and kiosk, according to its support FAQ, and the guest data stays in one system.
- You run neither, or run outlets on different systems. Neither built-in tool is designed for you. A standalone programme is the fit.
- You plan to change POS. A loyalty programme tied to the till has to be rebuilt, and members join again. See how to switch loyalty apps for a short overlap plan.
If you run a restaurant and are still choosing, our guide to choosing a restaurant loyalty program covers the wider decision.
Do you need tiers, bonus promotions and messaging?
Both vendors offer all three, in different forms. Each adds a rule. A tier means thresholds and a status to explain. A bonus promotion means dates to remember. Messaging means consent and content to manage, and a cost per message you should ask about.
Neither page states point-to-dollar rates, reward caps or expiry rules in the text we read. If those matter, ask for them in writing.
If you use tiers or bonus days every week and can name what they bring, the built-in tool earns its place. If you do not, you carry the rules without using them.
What is the points-only view?
Our view is that the simplest programme wins, because every customer already understands spend, earn and redeem. Tiers, bonus multipliers and item rules add things a customer has to learn. That is a position, and the research on it is mixed. Our case for points-only loyalty sets out the evidence and where it is thin.
Applied here, both Square and Toast can run plain points, because both list points by amount spent. The extras are optional. A points-only tool removes the option, which keeps the programme easy to explain at the counter.
You give things up with a points-only tool. You get no built-in tiers, no scheduled bonus promotions and no SMS or email campaigns. If you rely on those, a points-only tool will not replace them.
Price matters too. Per-location charges grow as you add outlets, so check how each tool bills before you open a second site. Our no per-location fees guide shows how vendors charge as you grow.
Where does Gimify fit?
Gimify is a hosted, points-only programme that works with whichever till you run. Customers scan a QR code and enter their email, with no app download, and the member card can be saved to Google Wallet. Staff add or redeem points on any phone at the counter, and one points balance works across every outlet. It is free for one outlet with unlimited members, and US$99 a month covers unlimited outlets with no per-member or per-location fees. It has no tiers, no stamp mode and no SMS or email campaigns. You can start free and run it beside your current till.
Questions owners ask
Is Square Loyalty or Toast Loyalty better for a small shop?
Neither wins in general. Square Loyalty belongs to Square's payments and point of sale, and Toast Loyalty to Toast POS for restaurants. The better one is usually the one that matches the till you already run. If you want a card that works at any counter, compare a standalone tool too.
How much does Square Loyalty cost compared with Toast Loyalty?
We cannot state a price for either. Square's loyalty page offers a 30-day free trial and shows no plan price. Toast's loyalty page shows a See Pricing button and no figure. Both pages were read on 15 November 2026. Ask each vendor for a written price for your location.
Can I use Toast Loyalty without Toast POS?
Toast's loyalty page describes the product as loyalty for restaurants using the Toast POS platform. It describes no version for other systems. Confirm with Toast if you run something else.
Do Square and Toast both offer tiers?
Square's page lists VIP tiers with 1.5x, 2x and 3x points. Toast's support FAQ covers tiered cash rewards. Gimify has no tiers and uses points based on purchase amount only.
Which one earns points on cash sales?
Square's page says points are earned even when customers pay with cash. We did not see the same statement on Toast's pages, so ask Toast how cash sales are entered at your counter.
What if I do not want to be tied to either till?
A standalone points programme works at any counter and survives a change of payment provider. Gimify is hosted, points-only and free for one outlet, and staff add points on any phone.
Read next
Start free
Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.
Start free See plans