Guides

SumUp Loyalty (Fivestars) Alternatives for Small Shops

By , founder of Stridec · Updated

In short Fivestars alternatives matter because fivestars.com now redirects to SumUp, and SumUp's loyalty pricing page, checked 15 November 2026, lists plans from US$199 to US$349 a month with no free tier. If you run one small shop, a free points card is enough to test whether members come back. Gimify is points-only, free for one outlet, and US$99 a month for unlimited outlets.

How it works in Gimify: the customer shows the QR on their phone, staff key in the bill on the counter tablet, and points land straight away. No app for the customer to download.

What are the main Fivestars alternatives for a small shop?

Fivestars was a loyalty and marketing product for local merchants. On 15 November 2026 the address fivestars.com sent us by permanent redirect to a SumUp page, and that page sells a product called SumUp Connect. The SumUp pages we read never use the name Fivestars, so we describe this as what the redirect shows and nothing more.

Owners who search for Fivestars alternatives are usually one of two people. Some are current customers who have seen the price and want to compare. Others used to know Fivestars and want a loyalty tool with a price they can read.

Three questions sort the options. What does it cost at your real number of outlets? Does it need a particular till or card reader? How many rules must a customer learn before the card pays off?

We opened each vendor’s own pages on 15 November 2026 and recorded only what they state. Where a page showed no figure, we left it out. Prices change, so read each page before you buy.

What does SumUp Connect cost?

SumUp’s loyalty pricing page lists four monthly prices.

PlanPrice shownWhat the page says it includes
Connect PlusUS$269 a monthCustomer Directory, AutoPilot messaging, 2 standard promos a month
Connect ProUS$349 a monthEverything in Plus, plus “UNLIMITED AI-enhanced messaging, review boost, and text-to-join capabilities”
POS with Connect PlusUS$199 a month“2 monthly promotions”, cloud-based POS
POS with Connect ProUS$289 a month“UNLIMITED marketing promotions”, cloud-based POS

Source: SumUp Connect pricing, checked 15 November 2026. The text we retrieved placed each price above its plan name, so the pairing above is our reading of the layout.

The same page says “No hidden fees. No surprise charges. No complicated contracts.” It lists a “Money Back Guarantee” without its terms. It gives no contract length, setup fee or cancellation rule, and no free plan. We could not find a hardware requirement for Connect on the pages we read.

If SumUp Connect is on your shortlist, ask for the contract length, the money-back terms and the hardware requirement in writing.

What does SumUp Connect include?

SumUp’s loyalty pages describe Connect as “an always-on marketing and customer loyalty tool” that “links each purchase to a personal connection, like rewards, offers, and automated messages.” The feature list covers Loyalty and Rewards, AutoPilot messaging, Review Boost, which can offer a reward as a thank you for a review, and Customer Acquisition, where your business appears on nearby customers’ screens.

The pages do not say how rewards are earned. They do not state whether customers collect points, visits or spend. So we cannot compare the reward mechanic, only the bundle around it.

That bundle is mostly marketing: messaging, promotions and review requests. If you will write and send campaigns every week, you may use what you pay for. If you want a card that awards points and redeems them, most of the price buys things you will not use.

Which Fivestars alternatives publish a price?

Four options publish prices on their own pages, all read on 15 November 2026.

OptionPrice shownHow it rewardsSource
LoyverseLoyalty programme free. Paid add-ons US$7 to US$25 a month per store, such as unlimited sales history and employee managementListed as a feature of its POS. The page gives no reward mechanicLoyverse pricing
FaveCardFree US$0, Pro US$39 a month, Business US$59 a month. Free and Pro allow 1 active cardDigital stamp cardsFaveCard pricing
7StampFree Forever US$0 (1 staff login, 25 card operations and 100 emails a month). Growth US$35 a month per login for the first 9 loginsStamp cards, with Apple Wallet and Google Wallet support listed7Stamp pricing
GimifyFree for one outlet. US$99 a month for unlimited outletsPoints earned in proportion to purchase amountGimify

Loyverse is a POS, so using its loyalty programme means running its POS too. FaveCard and 7Stamp are standalone tools built around stamps, the more complex mechanic. We go through the Loyverse side in Loyverse alternatives. For a restaurant on a different till, our Toast Loyalty alternatives page does the same exercise.

How do the monthly costs compare across a year?

The simplest comparison is twelve months of the listed monthly price for one shop, before tax and before any add-on. These are our multiplications of the figures above, not figures any vendor states.

OptionListed monthly priceTwelve months
SumUp POS with Connect PlusUS$199US$2,388
SumUp Connect PlusUS$269US$3,228
SumUp Connect ProUS$349US$4,188
FaveCard ProUS$39US$468
7Stamp Growth, 1 loginUS$35US$420
Gimify, one outletUS$0US$0

FaveCard and 7Stamp publish yearly billing that costs less than twelve monthly payments. Use their page for that. Our guide to how much a loyalty program costs shows how the same programme grows in cost as you add outlets and staff.

What rules does each option add for your customers?

Every feature on a loyalty plan is a rule. Messaging needs consent and content. A promotion needs a calendar and a limit. A review reward needs a prompt at the right moment. Stamps need a card with a number of boxes and a rule about what counts as a visit.

Customers already understand spending money and getting points back. Our view is that the simplest programme wins, but that is a position and the research on it is mixed. Our case for points-only loyalty sets out the evidence and where it is thin.

You give things up with a points-only tool. You get no built-in messaging, no scheduled promotions and no review requests. If you send campaigns weekly and they bring people in, a points-only tool will not replace that.

When should you stay with SumUp Connect?

Stay if you use the messaging and promotion tools often and can point to customers they brought back. Stay if you already run SumUp’s POS and the bundle price of US$199 or US$289 a month is lower than buying the pieces separately.

Consider an alternative if you want a price below four figures a year, if you want a free plan to test with real customers, or if you run a different till. Moving has a cost. Members must join again, so switching a loyalty app works best with a short overlap and a prompt at the counter.

Where does Gimify fit?

Gimify is a hosted, points-only loyalty programme that works at any counter. Customers scan a QR code and enter their email, with no app download, and the member card can be saved to Google Wallet. Staff add or redeem points on any phone, and one points balance works across every outlet. It is free for one outlet with unlimited members, and US$99 a month covers unlimited outlets with no per-member or per-location fees. It has no tiers, no stamp mode and no SMS or email campaigns. You can start free with one outlet.

Questions owners ask

What happened to Fivestars?

On 15 November 2026 the address fivestars.com returned a permanent redirect to a SumUp loyalty page, and the SumUp page names its product SumUp Connect. The SumUp pages we read did not mention Fivestars by name.

How much does SumUp Connect cost?

SumUp's loyalty pricing page, checked 15 November 2026, lists Connect Plus at US$269 a month and Connect Pro at US$349 a month. Bundled with SumUp POS it lists US$199 and US$289 a month. The page gave no contract length or setup fee, so ask SumUp for those in writing.

Is there a free alternative to SumUp Connect?

Yes. Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Loyverse lists its loyalty programme as free inside its POS. FaveCard and 7Stamp have free plans with limits, and both are built on stamps.

Do I have to use SumUp card readers or POS for SumUp Connect?

The SumUp pages we read did not state a hardware requirement, and they did not rule one out. They list POS bundles at lower monthly prices. Ask SumUp whether Connect works with your current till before you sign.

What does a small shop actually need from a loyalty programme?

Most small shops need a way to sign customers up at the counter, award points on each sale and redeem them. Messaging, promotions and review tools are extra rules and extra monthly cost. Test the basic version first.

Will my members move if I switch?

Not automatically. Members have to join the new programme. Run both for a few weeks, tell members at the counter and ask your current vendor what member data you can export.

Read next

Start free

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.

Start free See plans