Square Loyalty Alternatives for Small Shops: Prices and Rules
By Alva Chew, founder of Stridec · Updated
In short Square Loyalty alternatives are worth a look if you want a price you can read before you commit. Square's loyalty page, checked 15 November 2026, offers a 30-day free trial and shows no plan price, and its pricing page would not load for us. If you want a points card that works at any counter, a points-only programme such as Gimify is free for one outlet and US$99 a month for unlimited outlets.
What are the main Square Loyalty alternatives?
Square Loyalty is the loyalty product that sits next to Square’s payments and point of sale. Owners who search for Square Loyalty alternatives usually fall into two groups. Some run Square at the till and want to know whether an outside tool beats the built-in one. Others use another system, or are leaving Square, and want a loyalty programme that does not depend on a particular till.
Three questions decide most of it. What does it cost at your real number of locations? How many rules must a customer learn before the card pays off? Does it work if you change your payment provider?
We opened Square’s loyalty page and the pages of each alternative on 15 November 2026 and recorded only what they state. Where a page failed to load or showed no figure, we left the figure out. Prices change, so read each vendor’s page before you buy.
What does Square Loyalty cost?
We could not find a price we can state. Square’s loyalty page says “Try Square Loyalty free for 30 days” and says there are no hidden fees or locked-in contracts. It names no plan price and sends you to Square’s pricing page. That pricing page, and two other Square pages we tried, returned an error (HTTP 429, too many requests) when we opened them. So we do not quote a Square monthly price here.
| Item | What we saw | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Free trial | “Try Square Loyalty free for 30 days” | Square Loyalty, checked 15 November 2026 |
| Plan price | Not on the loyalty page. Pricing page did not load | Square pricing, checked 15 November 2026 |
| Contract | “No hidden fees or locked-in contracts” | Square Loyalty page |
Before you compare, open Square’s pricing page for your country and write down the monthly price for each location you run. Square’s own pages for other countries may differ from the US page, so use the one that matches where you trade.
What rules does Square Loyalty have?
Square’s loyalty page describes the following.
| Rule | What the page says |
|---|---|
| Earning | Points based on visits, amount spent, or items and categories purchased |
| Cash sales | Points are earned even when customers pay with cash |
| Sign-up | At the point of sale, on a Square website, or through an invoice |
| Promotions | Limited-time or recurring bonus-point promotions |
| Tiers | VIP tiers: Bronze 1.5x, Silver 2x, Gold 3x points per purchase |
| Redemption | In store or online, such as a dollar amount off or a free item |
| Messages | Transactional texts sent when points or rewards are earned |
Source: Square Loyalty, checked 15 November 2026.
The page does not state point-to-dollar rates, reward caps, expiry rules or what texts cost. If any of those matter to you, ask Square in writing. So Square Loyalty covers plain points, but also earning by visit, by item, tiers and bonus promotions. Each is another rule for staff to run and for a customer to learn.
Which Square Loyalty alternatives publish a price?
These three show prices on their own pages, each read on 15 November 2026.
| Option | Price shown | How it rewards | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loyverse | Loyalty programme listed among free tools. Paid add-ons US$7 to US$25 a month per store, such as unlimited sales history at US$7 | Feature of its POS. Page gives no reward mechanic | Loyverse pricing |
| FaveCard | Free US$0, Pro US$39 a month, Business US$59 a month, plus tax. Yearly US$390 and US$590 | Digital stamp cards. Free and Pro allow one active card at a time. Free cards cannot be added to Apple or Google Wallet | FaveCard pricing |
| Loopy Loyalty | Starter $25 a month, Growth $69, Ultimate $95, currency not named. 15-day trial | Stamp cards with a stamper app. 1, 3 and 10 locations by plan | Loopy pricing |
Loyverse is a POS, so its loyalty programme means running its POS too. See our Loyverse alternatives page for that choice. FaveCard and Loopy are standalone card tools built around stamps, the more complex mechanic. Our Loopy Loyalty alternatives page covers both in more detail. If you are weighing a restaurant POS instead, our Toast Loyalty alternatives page reads Toast’s pages the same way.
How do you compare a Square Loyalty alternative on price?
Price each option at the locations you will run in a year, then add anything that costs extra.
- Is the price per location, per user or per member? Loopy’s tiers cap locations at 1, 3 and 10. Gimify has no per-member or per-location fees. Our no per-location fees guide shows how vendors charge as you grow.
- Is the price public in your country? If you cannot read it, get it in writing.
- Can you try it with real customers? A free plan with no time limit lets you test before you pay. A trial ends, so note the date.
- What happens at location two? One points balance across outlets keeps members from splitting their points.
- Does it depend on your payment provider? A standalone tool keeps your loyalty programme if you change processor.
Do you need tiers, bonus promotions and item rules?
Square offers all three. A tier means thresholds and a status to explain. A bonus promotion means dates to remember. Item rules mean staff must know which products earn what.
Our view is that the simplest programme wins, because every customer already understands spend, earn and redeem. That is a position, and the research on it is mixed. Our case for points-only loyalty sets out the evidence and where it is thin.
You give things up with a points-only tool. You get no built-in tiers, no scheduled bonus promotions and no SMS or email campaigns. If you use those every week, a points-only tool will not replace them.
When should you stay with Square Loyalty?
Stay if you take payments with Square and want points, orders and customer records in one place, and you can name what tiers or bonus promotions bring you. Stay if the price on Square’s page for your location suits your volume.
Consider an alternative if you plan to leave Square, run outlets on different systems, or want a price you can read before you sign up. Moving has a cost. Members must join again, so switching a loyalty app works best with a short overlap and a prompt at the counter.
Where does Gimify fit?
Gimify is a hosted, points-only loyalty programme that does not depend on your till. Customers scan a QR code and enter their email, with no app download, and the member card can be saved to Google Wallet. Staff add or redeem points on any phone at the counter, and one points balance works across every outlet. It is free for one outlet with unlimited members, and US$99 a month covers unlimited outlets with no per-member or per-location fees. It has no tiers, no stamp mode and no SMS or email campaigns. You can start free with one outlet.
Questions owners ask
What are the best Square Loyalty alternatives for a small shop?
It depends on whether you keep Square for payments. If you do, check what Square charges for your location. If you want a card that works at any counter, compare standalone tools. Gimify is a points-only option that is free for one outlet.
How much does Square Loyalty cost?
Square's loyalty page, checked 15 November 2026, offers a 30-day free trial and gives no plan price. Its pricing page returned an error when we tried to open it, so we state no figure. Read the price for your country and location on Square's own page.
Does Square Loyalty use points?
Yes. Square's page says customers earn points based on visits, amount spent, or items and categories purchased. It also lists VIP tiers with 1.5x, 2x and 3x points. Gimify uses points based on purchase amount only, with no tiers.
Is there a free alternative to Square Loyalty?
Gimify has a free plan for one outlet with unlimited members, a Google Wallet card and QR sign-up, with no time limit. Loyverse's pricing page, checked 15 November 2026, lists its loyalty programme among its free tools.
Do customers earn points on cash purchases at Square?
Square's loyalty page says yes, points are earned even when customers pay with cash. Check how staff enter cash sales at your own counter before you rely on it.
Will my members move if I switch?
Not automatically. Members have to join the new programme. Plan a short overlap, tell members at the counter and ask Square what member data you can export.
Read next
Start free
Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.
Start free See plans