Guides

Your Loyalty Program's First 30 Days: What to Do and What to Expect

By , founder of Stridec · Updated

In short In a new loyalty program's first month, spend week 1 getting staff to ask everyone, week 2 getting members to earn a second time, week 3 getting the first redemption done, and week 4 reading your own numbers. Expect redemptions to be rare at first, since one retailer study found only 3% of purchases involved a redemption (Stourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015). Judge the month against your own previous weeks, not a benchmark.

What happens in a loyalty program’s first 30 days?

Four things, in order. Staff learn to ask, members earn a second time, the first rewards get redeemed, and you get enough numbers to judge the program against your own history. Each week has one job, and trying to do all four at once is the usual reason a launch feels messy.

This page assumes you have already launched. If you have not, start with how to start a loyalty program in a busy shop. What follows is the month after the poster goes up.

WeekOne jobWhat you count
1Every customer gets askedNew members per shift divided by transactions
2New members earn a second timeMembers who came back after joining
3First redemptions go smoothlyRedemptions and staff questions
4Read the numbers and change one thingAll of the above against your earlier weeks

What should you do in week 1?

Get the ask to happen at every payment. Sign-up is where most programs lose their members, because a poster alone asks the customer to start something and a person asks them for a yes or no. In one experiment, face-to-face requests succeeded about 70% of the time against about 10% for emailed ones.

FindingScopeSource
Face-to-face requests succeeded about 70%, emailed requests about 10%Experiment 1, 45 college students each asking 10 strangers to fill in a surveyRoghanizad and Bohns, 2016

Source: Association for Psychological Science summary of Roghanizad and Bohns, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2016. The authors call the findings exploratory and the samples were students, so read it as a direction and not as your sign-up rate.

Practical steps for the first seven days:

  • Give staff one fixed sentence, such as “Want points on this order? Scan this and they’re yours today.” The wording is in how to get customers to join your loyalty program.
  • Keep a tally of members joined at the end of each shift, and divide by transactions.
  • Make sure everyone who touches payment can add points on their own phone. The 15-minute staff training covers this.

Expect uneven results across shifts. One person will get twice the sign-up rate of another. Ask the better one what they say, and copy it.

What should you do in week 2?

Focus on the second purchase. A member who joined and never returned is a name on a list, and the second visit is where the program starts to do any work. Count members who made another purchase within a few days of joining, divided by members who joined. That share is your early repeat rate.

The earn rule matters most here. A customer who joins on a US$6 order should be able to see how one more order moves them toward the first reward. If the first reward needs thirty visits, nobody feels progress. Work the numbers with how to set your points earn rate, and put the first reward within a few weeks of a regular’s normal visits.

At the counter, tell new members once, in one line, what their balance is and what the first reward is. Do not explain the whole program again.

What should you do in week 3?

Walk the first redemptions through carefully. The first redemption is the moment a member decides whether joining was worth it, and a hesitant cashier makes it feel like a favour.

Expect few of them. Research on a retailer with a simple points program found redemptions in only 3% of purchases, and 60% of customers never redeemed over the 43 months studied. Customers who did redeem had baskets 25% larger and visited 141% more often, but that is an association, and the authors say hoarding was driven mostly by cognitive and psychological motives.

FindingScopeSource
Redemption in 3% of purchases, 60% of customers never redeemed in 43 months, 1% of spend earned as pointsOne Latin American home and hardware retailer, customers who joined in January 2008Stourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015
Redeemers’ baskets 25% larger, visits 141% more frequentSame study, an association and not proof of causeStourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015

Source: Stourm, Bradlow and Fader, Journal of Marketing Research, April 2015, read from the paper, opened 20 November 2026.

That retailer earned 1% of spend, a slow rate for a shop that sees customers weekly. The lesson for you is practical. If nobody has redeemed by week 3, the reward is probably too far away or staff are not mentioning it. See how to measure a loyalty program and the glossary entry on redemption rate for how to count it.

What should you do in week 4?

Read your numbers and make one change. By now you have about four weeks of counts: new members per transaction, returning members and redemptions. Compare each week with the one before, and compare the month with your normal weeks before launch.

Do not compare yourself with a benchmark. No independent public figure says what a good sign-up rate is for a small shop, and the figures vendors quote come from their own customers. Your earlier weeks are the only fair comparison.

Then change one thing. If sign-ups are low, change the ask sentence or the poster position. If members join but do not return, shorten the distance to the first reward. If members do not redeem, have staff mention the balance at payment. Changing two things together means you cannot tell which one worked.

What should you expect from the first month?

Modest results and a pattern that is still forming. A study of a convenience store franchise’s loyalty program found that low and moderate buyers changed most within three months of joining, and that heavy buyers claimed their rewards but did not raise their spending.

FindingScopeSource
Low and moderate buyers changed most within three months of joining, then grew more slowly. Heavy buyers claimed rewards but their spending did not increaseLongitudinal data from one convenience store franchiseLiu, Journal of Marketing, October 2007

Source: Liu, Journal of Marketing 71(4), 2007, read through the author’s summary page, opened 20 November 2026.

Two things follow. First, a month is the start, so judge repeat visits again at about three months. Second, your best customers will not spend much more because of the program. The members who matter most for growth are the occasional buyers who start coming back.

If the month goes badly, loyalty program not working? 7 signs and how to fix it lists the usual causes and fixes.

What does month one look like on Gimify?

On Gimify, members join by scanning the QR code and entering an email, with no app and no password, and staff add or redeem points on any phone at the counter. The free plan covers one outlet with unlimited members and has no time limit, so you can run all four weeks before deciding whether you need more. Members’ balances show on their phone web card, which makes the “here is your balance” line in week 2 easy to say.

Questions owners ask

What should I do in the first month of a loyalty program?

Week 1, get every staff member asking every customer. Week 2, make sure new members earn a second time. Week 3, walk the first redemptions through carefully. Week 4, count members, returning members and redemptions and compare them with your own earlier weeks.

How many customers should join in the first month?

No independent public figure says what share of customers join a small shop's program, so ignore any benchmark you are quoted. Count new members divided by transactions each shift and compare week with week.

Why is nobody redeeming my points yet?

Low redemption early on is common. In one retailer's program only 3% of purchases had a redemption and 60% of customers never redeemed in 43 months. Check that the first reward is reachable in a few visits and that staff mention it.

When will I see repeat visits increase?

Research on a convenience store franchise program found that low and moderate buyers changed most within three months of joining. Treat the first month as the start of the pattern, and look at repeat visits again at about three months.

What should I change if sign-ups are low after two weeks?

Change one thing at a time. Usually the wording of the staff ask or the position of the QR poster. If you change both together you cannot tell which one helped.

Do I need to email or text members in the first month?

No. The main work is at the counter: asking, adding points and handling the first redemptions. Recognising members in person does more in month one than any message.

Read next

Start free

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.

Start free See plans