Guides

Loyalty Program Not Working? 7 Signs and How to Fix It

By , founder of Stridec · Updated

In short A loyalty program is not working when customers cannot say what they earn, members join but never redeem, few customers join at all, or you cannot see any change in visits. Check each sign against your own records, then fix the simplest cause first: one earn rule, one named reward within a few visits, and one scan to join. A points program has the fewest rules to explain, so it is the easiest kind to repair.

How do you know your loyalty program is not working?

You know when the numbers you can already see stop matching what you expected. Few customers join, members do not come back sooner, balances grow and nobody redeems, or staff stop mentioning the program. Any one of these is a signal. Two or three together mean the program needs repair.

The seven signs below are a checklist. Each one has a quick test using records you have or a five-minute conversation at the counter, and a fix you can make this week. They are ordered by how often they turn out to be the real cause, so start at the top.

SignQuick test
1. Customers cannot say how they earnAsk five regulars
2. Members join and then disappearCount members with a second visit
3. Few customers joinSign-ups divided by customers served
4. Balances grow, redemptions do notPoints redeemed divided by points issued
5. Redeeming is slow or awkwardTime one redemption at the till
6. The reward costs too much or sits too far awayReward value divided by member spend
7. You cannot see any change in visitsCompare members with their own past

Source: Gimify checklist. The tests use your own records, so no benchmark is needed.

Sign 1: Do customers know what they earn?

If a regular cannot say how they earn and what comes next, the program is not working however good the reward is. Ask five regulars to explain it in one sentence. If the answers differ or begin with “I think”, that is the sign.

The research points the same way. KPMG surveyed over 18,000 consumers in 20 countries and reported that 60% agree loyalty programs are too hard to join and/or that earning rewards is a challenge. In Brazil and China the share was 80%.

FindingScopeSource
60% agree programs are too hard to join and/or earning rewards is a challengeOver 18,000 consumers, 20 countriesKPMG, 2019
80% agree in Brazil and ChinaSame surveyKPMG, 2019
55% of enrolled consumers use their programs a few times a month or lessSame surveyKPMG, 2019
49% of members agree they belong to too many programsSame surveyKPMG, 2019

Source: KPMG press release via PR Newswire, 26 November 2019. A global consumer survey about loyalty programs in general, so it shows how common the complaint is and not how your own customers feel.

Fix: one earn rule tied to spend, such as 1 point per US$1, and one reward named next to its point price. Say it in one sentence at payment. Our guide to setting your points earn rate has the arithmetic.

Sign 2: Do members join and then never come back?

A long member list with few returning members means the sign-up worked and the reason to return did not. Count members who made a second purchase within 30 days of joining, divided by members who joined. If most never reappear, the first reward is probably too far away or too vague.

An academic study of a home and hardware retailer’s points program shows that even a plain program can sit unused. Stourm, Bradlow and Fader followed customers who earned points at 1% of spend over 43 months.

FindingScopeSource
Customers redeemed in 3% of purchasesOne Latin American retailer, 1% of spend earned as pointsStourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015
60% of customers never redeemed in 43 months, 40% redeemed at least onceSame programStourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015
Of 244 customers who bought in 2011, 51.6% had never redeemedSame programStourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015

Source: Stourm, Bradlow and Fader, Journal of Marketing Research, April 2015. One retailer and one cohort, so read it as an example of what can happen.

The same paper reports that customers who redeemed at least once had baskets 25% larger and visited 141% more often than customers who never redeemed. That compares two types of customer. It does not show the reward caused the difference. It does show why a member who never redeems is worth chasing.

Fix: move the first reward within reach of a second or third visit. See why customers don’t redeem their points.

Sign 3: Do too few customers join?

If you serve 600 customers a month and 30 join, the program is invisible to most of your trade. Divide new sign-ups by customers served. The enrolment rate is yours to compare month to month, because no outside benchmark fits every shop.

Three causes come up most often.

  • Staff do not ask. Joining happens only when someone at the till says so. Make it part of payment.
  • Joining takes too long. An app download, a long form or a password each lose people at the counter. A QR scan and an email address is about as short as it gets.
  • The offer is not visible. A sign at the till with the earn rule and the first reward gives people a reason to scan.

Fix: shorten the join path first, then train the ask. The full method is in how to get customers to join your loyalty program.

Sign 4: Do balances grow while redemptions stay near zero?

Points issued rise every week and points redeemed barely move. Divide points redeemed by points issued over the last quarter. A rate close to zero means members are holding points they do not intend to use soon.

The Stourm study is again the best evidence we found on why. Redeeming could have cut a basket by nearly 30% on average, yet customers rarely did. The authors attribute the stockpiling mostly to cognitive and psychological motives. Their model also predicted what might change it. If redemption had been automatic above 15 points, predicted redemption over 11 months rose from 3.5% to 21.0%. That is a model prediction from the paper, not a field test.

Fix: make the reward easy to notice and easy to claim. Show the balance next to the reward price and let staff offer the redemption at payment instead of waiting for the customer to ask. Loyalty rewards customers actually redeem explains how to choose the reward.

Sign 5: Is redeeming slow or awkward at the counter?

Time one redemption from the moment the customer asks to the moment the receipt closes. If it takes longer than paying, a busy staff member will avoid offering it, and the program quietly stops working during the rush when it matters most.

Typical causes are a separate device or screen, a code the customer must find, and rules about which days or items are eligible. Each is another thing to explain.

Fix: one step at the same till, on any phone staff already carry, with no special days or exclusions. Check also that staff cannot be gamed. Loyalty fraud at the counter covers the controls.

Sign 6: Does the reward cost too much or sit too far away?

The reward can fail in two opposite ways, and both show up in the same ratio. Divide the value of rewards redeemed by member spend.

CaseWhat you seeWhat it usually means
Ratio near zeroFew redemptionsReward too far away or too small to notice
Ratio well above what your margin can carryMany redemptions, thinner profitReward too rich

Source: Gimify checklist.

Here is an illustrative US$ example. A café sets 1 point per US$1 and a free US$5 drink at 100 points. A customer spending US$8 a visit needs about 13 visits, which is more than a month for most regulars. Dropping the first reward to 50 points for a smaller item puts it within about 6 visits. The reward cost per US$1 of spend is the same ratio as before, so the only change is how soon the customer feels it. That example is our arithmetic, not a measured result. Use your own prices and margins, and see reward cost and margin before you change the rate.

Fix: keep the reward value near what your margin can carry and shorten the distance with a smaller first reward, not with a bigger one.

Sign 7: Can you see any change in visits?

If you cannot show that members visit more often than they did before joining, you cannot tell whether the program works. Regulars join first, so comparing members with non-members flatters the program. Compare each member with their own record before and after joining, over at least three months.

This sign has two causes. Either the program really has not changed behaviour, or the data does not tie purchases to a person and you cannot tell. The second is common in paper stamp cards, which leave no record. Our guide to loyalty program metrics sets out the five numbers to track, and is a loyalty program worth it has the break-even sum.

Fix: record every earn and redeem against one member. Without that, no other fix can be measured.

In what order should you fix these?

Fix the cheapest rule problems before you change tools or add features.

  1. Rewrite the earn rule and name the first reward (signs 1, 4 and 6). It costs nothing.
  2. Shorten joining and train the ask (sign 3).
  3. Speed up redeeming at the till (sign 5).
  4. Start measuring (signs 2 and 7), so each change can be judged after three months.
  5. Only then think about the tool. If the rules are clear and the join path is the problem, switch. Our guide to why customers ignore loyalty programs covers the clarity side in more depth.

Change one thing at a time. If you change the earn rate, the reward and the sign-up path in the same week, you will not know which one helped.

Adding tiers, stamps or games rarely helps. Each is a further rule to learn, and sign 1 is the most common failure.

Where Gimify fits

Gimify is a points-only programme, so the rules a customer learns are spend, earn points, redeem points. Customers join by scanning a QR code and entering their email, and staff add or redeem points on any phone at the counter. One points balance works across every outlet, and the free plan covers one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit.

Questions owners ask

Why is my loyalty program not working?

Most often because customers do not understand it or cannot reach the reward. KPMG's 2019 survey of over 18,000 consumers in 20 countries found 60% agree programs are too hard to join and/or that earning rewards is a challenge. Start by asking five regulars how they earn and what they get next.

How long should I wait before deciding a loyalty program has failed?

Give it about three months of real counter use, then compare members with their own visit history before they joined. Earlier than that, early joiners are mostly your existing regulars. If you have fixed the clarity problems and still see no change after a second quarter, test a different reward or a different tool.

Is a low redemption rate a sign the program is broken?

It is a sign to look closer, not proof of failure. In one academic study of a retailer's points program, customers redeemed in 3% of purchases and 60% never redeemed over 43 months, even though redeeming was easy. Check how far away the first reward is, whether customers know its value and how long redeeming takes at the till.

Should I add tiers, stamps or games to revive a program?

Usually not. Each addition is another rule customers have to learn, and unclear rules are the most common cause of an ignored program. Fix the plain version first: spend earns points and points buy a named reward.

Can I fix a loyalty program without new software?

Often yes. Rewriting the earn rule, moving the first reward closer and training staff to mention the program at payment cost nothing. Software matters when joining takes too long or you cannot see who is active, in which case a QR sign-up and one balance per customer solve it.

When is it better to switch loyalty program than to repair it?

When the cause is the tool, such as an app customers will not download, a join form that takes minutes or a price per location you cannot carry. If the rules are clear and customers still do not join, the sign-up path is the likely cause.

Read next

Start free

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.

Start free See plans