How Many Points Should a Free Coffee Cost?
By Alva Chew, founder of Stridec · Updated
In short At 1 point per US$1, most cafés should price a free coffee at 40 to 75 points, which returns about 7% to 12% of spend and costs you roughly 2% to 3% once you count what the drink costs to make. Pick the number by working out how many weeks your regular takes to reach it. A daily regular should get there in two to four weeks, and a once-a-week customer will take about two months at 50 points.
How many points should a free coffee cost?
At 1 point per US$1, set it between 40 and 75 points for a drink that sells at about US$5. That gives a give-back of 12.5% to 6.7% at menu price. Start at 50 points, which returns a clean 10%, and adjust after you check how many weeks your regulars take to reach it.
Our guide to setting your points earn rate covers the general method for any shop. Our guide to reward cost and margin shows how to prove a program pays. This page does one narrower job. It sets the reward threshold for a coffee, where the reward is one drink, the price is low and customers come back often.
What does a cup of coffee cost you to make?
Less than most owners guess for the coffee itself, and more once milk, cup, lid and labour go in. The reward costs you the second number, not the menu price.
For the beans, we can anchor on a published price. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics recorded ground roast coffee at US$9.249 a pound in October 2026, the US city average.
| Item | Figure | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Retail ground coffee, US city average, Oct 2026 | US$9.249 per lb | BLS average price data |
| Same price per kilogram | About US$20.39 | Our arithmetic (1 lb = 453.6 g) |
| Beans in an 18 g shot dose | About US$0.37 | Our arithmetic, assuming an 18 g dose |
Source: BLS Average Retail Food and Energy Prices, opened 21 November 2026. This is a supermarket price for ground coffee. A café buying wholesale or specialty beans will pay a different amount, so treat it as a marker and use your supplier invoice.
The 18 g dose is our assumption for a double shot. Everything else in a cup is yours to supply: milk, syrup, cup, lid, sleeve and the minute of staff time. The worked examples below use US$1.25 all in for a US$5 drink, the same illustrative figure as our other guides. Swap in yours.
Which threshold fits a US$5 drink?
Work from the give-back, then check how many weeks it takes. At 1 point per US$1, the threshold in points equals the spend needed in dollars.
Worked example A (illustrative figures, not a benchmark). A US$5 drink costing US$1.25 to make, so a cost share of 25%. Regular A spends US$6 a visit and visits 3 times a week, which is US$18 a week.
| Threshold | Spend to earn it | Give-back at menu price | Cost to you (25% cost share) | Weeks for Regular A |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 40 points | US$40 | 12.5% | 3.1% | 2.2 |
| 50 points | US$50 | 10.0% | 2.5% | 2.8 |
| 75 points | US$75 | 6.7% | 1.7% | 4.2 |
| 100 points | US$100 | 5.0% | 1.3% | 5.6 |
Source: our arithmetic. Give-back is US$5 divided by spend. Cost to you is the give-back multiplied by 25%. Weeks are spend divided by US$18.
Two things follow. Every 10 points you add to the threshold cuts the give-back and delays the reward, but the cost to you moves by well under a percentage point. And a 40-point threshold only costs about 0.6 percentage points more than 50 points while bringing the reward in about 4 days sooner. Most owners can afford the faster one.
Run the break-even test from the margin guide with your own gross margin before you settle. A 2.5% effective cost is small at a typical drinks margin, but your own invoices decide.
How long should the wait be for a coffee drinker?
Short, because coffee is a habit purchase. A field experiment at a café at Columbia University measured it.
| Finding | Scope | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Time between purchases fell about 20% (roughly 0.7 days) as members neared a free coffee | Café reward program at Columbia University | Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, 2006 |
Source: Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, “The Goal-Gradient Hypothesis Resurrected”, Journal of Marketing Research, 2006. The reward in the study was a stamp card, so we use it as evidence that nearness to a free drink speeds visits, not as a case for any card format.
That pull needs the reward to be reachable. A working rule for coffee is two to four weeks for a customer who comes in a few times a week. The table above puts 40, 50 and 75 points inside that window for Regular A.
What about customers who visit once a week?
They set the ceiling on how high you can go. Take a second regular and see what the same thresholds do.
Worked example B. Regular B spends US$6 once a week.
| Threshold | Weeks for Regular B | Weeks for Regular A (3 visits a week) |
|---|---|---|
| 40 points | 6.7 | 2.2 |
| 50 points | 8.3 | 2.8 |
| 75 points | 12.5 | 4.2 |
| 100 points | 16.7 | 5.6 |
Source: our arithmetic, illustrative spend of US$6 a visit.
At 100 points a weekly customer waits about four months for a US$5 drink, which is long enough to forget the card exists. At 50 points they wait about two months. If most of your members look like Regular B, lower the threshold or accept that your reward will mainly reach the people who visit most. Your own ledger will show which group you have.
How do you handle drinks at different prices?
Name the reward as one drink up to a stated price, and let the customer pay any difference. A US$4 filter coffee and a US$6.50 oat flat white then both fit one threshold.
- Cap the value. “Any drink up to US$5.50” sets your maximum cost per reward.
- Let the customer top up. A customer who wants a US$6.50 drink pays US$1.
- Count the food too. A US$6 drink with a US$4 pastry earns 10 points, so ticket size lifts progress. This is the advantage of earning on spend. A single flat per-drink award would treat a black coffee and a loaded breakfast the same.
If you prefer a rule that sounds like a classic card, such as “every tenth drink free”, the points version is 50 points on a US$5 drink at 1 point per US$1. Customers get the same result from one rule, and the balance grows with larger orders.
Should the earn rate be 1 or 10 points per dollar?
Either, as long as the threshold scales with it. The give-back is what counts.
| Earn rate | Threshold | Reward | Give-back at menu price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 point per US$1 | 50 points | US$5 drink | 10% |
| 10 points per US$1 | 500 points | US$5 drink | 10% |
| 2 points per US$1 | 100 points | US$5 drink | 10% |
Source: our arithmetic.
Stay with 1 point per US$1 unless your tickets are small. At a US$3 drink, a ticket earns only 3 points, and some owners prefer bigger numbers on the screen. The earn-rate guide has the full rounding rules, including awarding points on whole dollars.
When should you change the threshold?
After a price rise, after your first month of data, and if members stall. Prices move the give-back without you touching a setting.
Worked example C (our arithmetic, illustrative prices). You keep the threshold at 50 points and raise the drink from US$5.00 to US$5.50. Customers still spend US$50 to earn it. The reward is now worth US$5.50, so the give-back at menu price rises from 10.0% to 11.0%. Cost at a 25% cost share goes from 2.5% to 2.75%. If cost per drink also rose, check that against the margin test.
Look at three numbers after four weeks:
- Share of members who have reached the first reward. If almost none have, the threshold is too high for your visit pattern.
- Redemption. Points redeemed over points issued, by month of issue. Our points liability guide shows the cohort view.
- Cost per reward. The cost of the drinks actually given away, against the member spend in the same weeks.
Raising a threshold upsets regulars who are already saving, so give notice and honour balances already earned. Lowering it is always welcome. For wider ideas on rewards beyond the free drink, see our café loyalty program ideas and the coffee shop page.
Setting your free coffee in Gimify
Gimify awards points in proportion to each purchase, so a latte with a pastry earns more than a filter coffee on its own, and staff add or redeem points on any phone at the counter. The free plan covers one outlet with unlimited members, and customers join by scanning a QR code with their email, with no app to download.
Questions owners ask
How many points should a free coffee cost?
At 1 point per US$1, 50 points suits a US$5 drink. That is a 10% give-back at menu price. Move to 40 points for a faster first reward or 75 to 100 points if your margin is thin.
Should the earn rate be 1 point per dollar or 10?
Both give the same result if the threshold scales with it. 1 point per US$1 with 50 points for a drink matches 10 points per US$1 with 500 points. Use 1 per US$1 unless your tickets are small and you want visible progress on each one.
What does a free coffee really cost me?
Only the cost of the drink, not its menu price. With a US$5 latte that costs US$1.25 to make, a 10% give-back costs you about 2.5% of member spend. Replace the US$1.25 with your own figure from your invoices.
How long should a regular take to earn a free coffee?
Two to four weeks for someone who visits several times a week. Research at a Columbia University café found customers bought faster as they neared a free coffee, so a reward that sits months away loses that effect.
What if customers order drinks of different prices?
Set the reward as one drink up to a stated price, for example any drink up to US$5.50. Anyone ordering something dearer pays the difference. This keeps the cost predictable on a varied menu.
Do I need to change the threshold when I raise prices?
Check it. If the threshold stays at 50 points and the drink goes from US$5 to US$5.50, the give-back at menu price rises from 10% to 11%. A small rise is usually fine, but recheck after any large price change.
Read next
Start free
Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.
Start free See plans