Guides

Fivestars Alternatives for Independent Shops and Cafés

By , founder of Stridec · Updated

In short Fivestars alternatives are worth comparing because fivestars.com now redirects to SumUp's Connect page, which lists plans from US$199 to US$349 a month and no free plan (checked 20 November 2026). A café with one counter can test a card for free before paying for messaging tools. Gimify is points-only, free for one outlet with no time limit, and US$99 a month for unlimited outlets.

How it works in Gimify: the customer shows the QR on their phone, staff key in the bill on the counter tablet, and points land straight away. No app for the customer to download.

What are the best Fivestars alternatives for an independent shop or café?

Fivestars was a loyalty and marketing product for local merchants. On 20 November 2026 the address fivestars.com sent us by permanent redirect to SumUp’s loyalty page, which sells a product called SumUp Connect. That page never uses the name Fivestars, so we say only what the redirect shows.

Owners who search for Fivestars alternatives tend to be in one of two positions. Some are current customers who have seen the price and want to compare. Others want a loyalty tool for one café or shop and want to see a price before they talk to anyone.

Three questions sort the options. What does it cost at your real number of outlets? Do you need messaging and promotions, or only a card that awards and redeems points? How many rules must a customer learn before the card pays off?

We opened each vendor’s own page on 20 November 2026 and recorded only what it states. Where a page showed no figure, we left the figure out. Prices change, so read each page before you buy. We also give the older write-up of the same redirect in SumUp Loyalty (Fivestars) alternatives, and this page adds the independent shop and café view.

What does the page behind Fivestars list?

SumUp’s pricing page lists four monthly prices.

PlanPrice shownWhat the page says it includes
Connect PlusUS$269 a monthCustomer Directory, AutoPilot messaging, 2 standard promos a month
Connect ProUS$349 a monthAll of Plus, plus unlimited AI-enhanced messaging, review boost and text-to-join
POS with Connect PlusUS$199 a monthCloud-based POS, customer rewards, 2 monthly promotions, weekly SMS and email promotions
POS with Connect ProUS$289 a monthCloud-based POS, customer rewards, unlimited marketing promotions, unlimited SMS and email promotions

Source: SumUp Connect pricing, checked 20 November 2026. The text we retrieved placed each price above its plan name, so the pairing is our reading of the layout.

The page describes Plus as for “growing businesses with multiple locations” and Pro as for “established businesses with multiple locations”. It says “No complicated contracts” and lists a money-back guarantee with a footnote we could not read. It gives no contract length, setup fee or free plan. Its feature list covers rewards, AutoPilot messaging, a customer database, Review Boost, where a business can offer a reward for a review, and Customer Acquisition, where your business shows on nearby customers’ screens. It does not say how customers earn rewards, so we cannot compare the reward mechanic, only the bundle.

Which Fivestars alternatives publish a price?

Each option below shows its price on its own page, read on 20 November 2026.

OptionPrice shownHow it rewardsSource
FaveCardFree US$0. Pro US$39 a month or US$390 a year. Business US$59 a month or US$590 a year. Plus tax. Free and Pro allow 1 card at a time. 30 days of premium tools free for new accountsDigital stamp cards. Wallet passes from Pro. Messages between visits and review requests on BusinessFaveCard pricing
7StampFree Forever US$0 with 1 staff login, 25 card operations and 100 emails a month. Growth US$35 a month per staff login for logins 1 to 9Stamp cards7Stamp pricing
LoyverseLoyalty programme free. Paid add-ons per store US$7, US$25 and US$25 a month, excluding taxA feature of its POS. The page gives no reward mechanicLoyverse pricing
Loopy LoyaltyStarter $25, Growth $69, Ultimate $95 a month, currency not named. 1, 3 and 10 locations. 15-day free trialStamp cardsLoopy pricing
GimifyFree for one outlet. US$99 a month for unlimited outletsPoints earned in proportion to purchase amountGimify

Loyverse is a POS, so using its loyalty programme means running its POS too. FaveCard, 7Stamp and Loopy are standalone tools built around stamps, the more complex mechanic. If your till is the real question, our SumUp Loyalty vs Square Loyalty page compares two POS vendors in the same way.

What does a year cost for one café?

The simplest comparison is twelve months of the listed monthly price for one shop, before tax and add-ons. These are our multiplications of the figures above, not figures any vendor states.

OptionListed priceTwelve months
SumUp POS with Connect PlusUS$199 a monthUS$2,388
SumUp Connect PlusUS$269 a monthUS$3,228
SumUp Connect ProUS$349 a monthUS$4,188
Loopy Starter$25 a month$300
FaveCard ProUS$39 a monthUS$468
7Stamp Growth, 1 loginUS$35 a monthUS$420
Gimify, one outletUS$0US$0

FaveCard, Loopy and 7Stamp publish yearly billing that costs less than twelve monthly payments, so use their pages for that. Our free loyalty program apps guide covers what the free plans limit.

Do you need messaging, promotions and review tools?

Every feature on a loyalty plan is a rule or a task. Messaging needs content and consent. A promotion needs a calendar and a limit. A review reward needs a prompt at the right moment. If someone on your team will do these every week, the bundle may earn its price, and you can check that by counting the customers a campaign brought back.

If you want a card that awards points on each sale and redeems them at the counter, most of a bundle’s price pays for tools you will not use. Customers already understand spending money and getting points back. Our view is that the simplest programme wins, but that is a position, and the research is mixed. Our case for points-only loyalty sets out the evidence and where it is thin.

You give things up with a points-only tool. You get no built-in messaging, no scheduled promotions and no review requests. If you send campaigns weekly and they bring people in, a points-only tool will not replace that.

How do you compare Fivestars alternatives at more than one outlet?

Price each option at the number of outlets you will run in a year, then add anything that costs extra.

  1. Is the price per outlet, per staff login or flat? Loopy’s plans cap locations at 1, 3 and 10. 7Stamp charges per staff login. Gimify is flat at US$99 a month for unlimited outlets.
  2. Is there a free plan with no time limit? A trial ends, so note the date. A free plan lets you test with real customers first.
  3. Do points carry across outlets? One balance across outlets keeps members from splitting their points.
  4. Does it need your till? SumUp lists POS bundles, and Loyverse’s programme sits inside its POS. Ask whether the tool works with the till you already own.

When should you stay with SumUp Connect?

Stay if you use the messaging and promotion tools often and can point to customers they brought back. Stay if you already run SumUp’s POS and the bundle price is lower than buying the pieces separately.

Consider an alternative if you want a price below four figures a year, want a free plan to test with real customers, or run a different till. Moving has a cost. Members must join again, so switching a loyalty app works best with a short overlap and a prompt at the counter.

Where does Gimify fit?

If you run one café or shop and want to test points before paying for anything, Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Customers scan a QR code and enter their email, with no app download, and the member card can be saved to Google Wallet. Staff add or redeem points on any phone, and one balance works across outlets at US$99 a month, with no per-member or per-location fees. It has no tiers, no stamp mode and no SMS or email campaigns. You can start free with one outlet.

Questions owners ask

Is Fivestars still available?

On 20 November 2026 fivestars.com returned a permanent redirect (301) to SumUp's loyalty page at sumup.com/en-us/loyalty-program/. That page sells SumUp Connect and does not mention Fivestars by name. Ask SumUp directly about the status of an existing Fivestars account.

How much does the SumUp Connect page list?

SumUp's pricing page, checked 20 November 2026, lists US$269 a month for Connect Plus and US$349 for Connect Pro. With SumUp's POS it lists US$199 and US$289 a month. It shows no free plan and no setup fee, and its money-back guarantee has a footnote we could not read.

What is a free alternative to Fivestars for one café?

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. FaveCard lists a free plan with one card at a time, and 7Stamp lists a free plan capped at 25 card operations a month. Both are built on stamps. Loyverse lists its loyalty programme as free inside its POS.

Do I need text or email campaigns to run a loyalty programme?

No. A programme can run on points alone, with customers earning on each purchase and redeeming at the counter. Campaign tools help if someone writes and sends them every week. Gimify has no SMS or email campaigns, so choose a tool with them if that is your plan.

Will my members move if I switch?

Not automatically. Members have to join the new programme. Run both for a few weeks, tell members at the counter and ask your current vendor what member data you can export.

Which option suits an independent shop with two or three outlets?

Price each option at your outlet count. Loopy's pages cap locations at 1, 3 and 10 by plan. 7Stamp charges per staff login. Gimify charges nothing for one outlet and a flat US$99 a month for unlimited outlets.

Read next

Start free

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.

Start free See plans