Guides

Low-Cost Rewards That Bring Regulars Back (and What They Cost You)

By , founder of Stridec · Updated

In short The cheapest rewards are small items that members add to a paid order, such as a size upgrade, an extra shot, a side or a topping. Price them in points with one formula: reward cost divided by the share of spend you can afford to give back. A reward redeemed alone can cost you its full menu price if the member would have bought it anyway, so require a purchase for the cheap ones.

How it works in Gimify: the customer shows the QR on their phone, staff key in the bill on the counter tablet, and points land straight away. No app for the customer to download.

What are the cheapest loyalty rewards a small business can give?

Small items a member adds to a paid order. A size upgrade, an extra shot, a topping, a side dish or a small bake with a drink all cost you a few cents to a couple of dollars, and each looks worth more to the member than it costs you. All of them are redeemed with points, so the member needs to learn only one rule: spend, earn, redeem.

Other pages on this site cover neighbouring questions. The guide to reward cost and margin gives the break-even test, and the page on how many points a free coffee should cost sets one threshold for one drink. This page answers a different question. Which rewards are cheap for you to give, and what points price makes each one stay cheap?

How do you turn a reward’s cost into a points price?

Start from what you can afford to give back, then work out the points price from your cost. At 1 point per US$1 spent, the formula is:

Points price = what the reward costs you ÷ the share of spend you can afford to give back

Write the share as a decimal, so 2.5% is 0.025. Our earlier guide to the points earn rate explains why a 1 point per US$1 rate keeps the arithmetic this simple. If you earn at another rate, scale the result by it.

Here is the formula run on five rewards with a 2.5% target. Every cost in the table is our own illustrative figure. Replace the middle column with your invoices.

RewardYour cost (example)Points price at a 2.5% targetGive-back the member sees at menu price
Size upgrade (menu value US$1)US$0.30128.3%
Extra shot or topping (menu value US$1)US$0.40166.3%
Drink (menu value US$5)US$1.255010.0%
Dessert (menu value US$10)US$3.001208.3%
US$5 off the billUS$5.002002.5%

Source: our arithmetic, illustrative US$ figures. Give-back at menu price is menu value divided by the spend needed to earn the reward.

Read the last column against the first. Every item reward looks like 6% to 10% back to the member, yet each costs you 2.5% of spend. Money off looks like 2.5% and costs 2.5%. The gap between what a reward is worth to the member and what it costs you is the reason to reward with an item.

Which low-cost rewards are worth offering?

Six that you can price with the formula above. Offer two or three, not all six, because a short list is easier for a member to value at a glance.

  1. Size upgrade. Cost is the extra milk or portion. It is the cheapest reward on the list and the fastest to reach, at about 12 points in the table.
  2. Extra shot, topping or sauce. A small add-on to a paid item. The member picks it at the counter, so it feels chosen, not handed over.
  3. A side or small bake with a drink. For example, an item with a US$3 menu price that costs you under US$1. Redeem it with a drink purchase.
  4. Dessert or starter at a quiet time. If the kitchen is idle on a weekday evening and the item uses stock you already hold, the real cost sits near your cost price. The guide to restaurant loyalty program ideas covers why guests respond to a dish more than to a discount.
  5. A free drink at a higher points price. Cheap to you at 50 points, but see the next section. It is the reward most likely to replace a sale.
  6. A sign-up head start. A small bonus when someone joins puts a first reward within a visit or two. Our page on the sign up bonus sizes it as a share of your first reward.

What these have in common is a points price you can afford at a low give-back. Anything that needs a long explanation is not a cheap reward, because the explaining costs staff time at the counter.

When does a free item cost more than you think?

When the member would have bought it anyway. The cost-price view assumes the reward is extra. If a regular who orders a US$5 latte every morning redeems 50 points for that same latte, you lose the US$5 sale, not US$1.25.

Use two cost rules:

  • Reward added to a paid order. An upgrade, add-on or side that comes with a purchase costs you its cost price. The order would have happened anyway, and the item is the only extra.
  • Reward that replaces a purchase. A free item the member would have bought costs you its menu price in lost sales, because you would have made the item either way.
RewardAdded to a paid orderReplaces a sale the member would have made
Size upgrade (US$0.30 cost, US$1 menu)US$0.30Not applicable, a purchase is needed
Free drink (US$1.25 cost, US$5 menu)US$1.25 if they also buy foodUS$5.00 in the worst case
Dessert (US$3 cost, US$10 menu)US$3.00US$10.00 in the worst case

Source: our arithmetic, illustrative figures. The worst case treats the lost menu price as the cost. Your real cost sits between the two columns and depends on how many redeemers were already buying the item.

The lesson for design is to set the reward as one drink or item up to a stated price, redeemable with a purchase of any size, and to price the pure free item a little higher. Then the cheap add-ons carry most of the redemptions, and the one that can replace a sale is saved for members who have earned it. Check which kind your members actually claim. Your points ledger shows it in a week.

How soon should a member reach the first reward?

Within a few visits. A field experiment at a Columbia University café found that the time between purchases fell by about 20%, roughly 0.7 days, as members neared a free coffee.

FindingScopeSource
Interpurchase time fell 20% (about 0.7 days) as members neared a free coffeeCafé reward programme at Columbia UniversityKivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, 2006

Source: Kivetz, Urminsky and Zheng, “The Goal-Gradient Hypothesis Resurrected”, Journal of Marketing Research, 2006. The reward in the study was a stamp card, so we use it only as evidence that nearness to a reward speeds visits, not as a case for any card format.

This is where cheap rewards earn their keep. A 12-point upgrade is a first reward that a regular reaches in about two visits at US$6 each, long before a 200-point money-off voucher would come into view. A low points price on a low-cost item gets members redeeming, which matters because many never do. In a study of one retailer’s points programme, redemptions were 3% of purchases and 60% of customers never redeemed in 43 months.

FindingScopeSource
Redemptions were 3% of purchases, and 60% of customers never redeemed over 43 monthsOne Latin American home and hardware retailer, points earned at 1% of spendStourm, Bradlow and Fader, 2015

Source: Stourm, Bradlow and Fader, Journal of Marketing Research, April 2015. That retailer is not a café, so read this as a warning about reach, not a forecast for your members. Our page on rewards customers redeem covers why points go unspent.

How do you check that a cheap reward is paying for itself?

Run the numbers on your own ledger after four to eight weeks, using three counts.

  1. Redemptions by reward. If one reward takes most of them, price that one first.
  2. Share that came with a purchase. For add-ons this should be nearly all. For free drinks, look at how many redeemers bought nothing else.
  3. Cost of rewards given against member spend over the same weeks, using your cost price for added items and menu price for replaced ones.

Then apply the break-even test in the margin guide to the total. If cost is above your target, raise the points price of the reward that replaces sales before touching the cheap ones. Raising a price upsets members who are saving, so give notice and honour balances already earned.

What about stamps, tiers and games as cheap rewards?

They add rules and, for you, more things to cost. A stamp card needs a decision on what earns a stamp, a tier scheme needs a threshold and a benefit per level, and a game needs prizes and odds. Each one makes the cost of the reward harder to work out. A points reward has one cost formula and one rule for the member, so you can copy the table above and fill it with your own numbers.

Where Gimify fits

Gimify awards points in proportion to each purchase, so the points price in your table matches what members earn, and staff redeem a reward on any phone at the counter. The free plan covers one outlet with unlimited members and has no time limit, so you can price your first rewards and watch redemptions before you spend anything.

Questions owners ask

What are cheap loyalty rewards for a small business?

Small items that cost you little to give and look worth more to the member: a size upgrade, an extra shot or topping, a side, a small bake with a drink, or a dessert in a quiet part of the week. Redeem them with points on top of a paid order.

How do I turn a reward's cost into a points price?

At 1 point per US$1 spent, divide what the reward costs you by the share of spend you can afford to give back, written as a decimal. A US$1.25 drink at a 2.5% target is 1.25 divided by 0.025, which is 50 points.

Is money off cheaper than a free item?

No. Money off costs its full face value every time, while a free item costs your cost price. At the same 2.5% target, a US$5 reward needs 200 points as money off and 50 points as a drink that costs you US$1.25.

Can a free item cost me its full menu price?

Yes. If the member would have bought that exact item anyway, the free one replaces a paid sale and you lose the menu price. Rewards that need a paid purchase alongside them add to the order instead, so your cost price is closer to the real cost.

Should cheap rewards come at a low points price?

Yes, a low price puts a first reward within a few visits. Research at a Columbia University café found visits came faster as members neared a free coffee, so a near reward pulls harder than a large far one.

Read next

Start free

Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.

Start free See plans