Rewards Programs for Small Businesses: How to Choose One
By Alva Chew, founder of Stridec · Updated
In short Choose a rewards program for your small business in six steps: set one reward you can afford, pick points over stamps or tiers, check the price at two outlets, test the sign-up on your own phone, brief staff, then launch at the counter. A points program that is free for one outlet lets you test it with real customers before you pay anything.
How do you choose a rewards program for a small business?
You choose it by working through the steps a shop would actually take, in order, and stopping at any step where an option fails. The order below runs from deciding what you can afford to give away through to the first week at the counter.
Most owners ask the same thing before they commit: does it change how often customers come back? You will not know from a vendor’s page. You will know from your own numbers after a few weeks, so the plan below is built around a test you can run cheaply.
Step 1: What reward can you afford to give?
Decide the reward before you look at any software. Your margin sets the limit, and a reward you cannot afford will be quietly dropped within a month.
Pick one reward and work out what it costs you:
- A free item costs you its cost price, not its menu or shelf price.
- Money off costs you the full amount.
- A reward that needs a big spend to reach will go unclaimed.
Our guide to setting your points earn rate walks through the arithmetic. A common way to start is to work backwards: choose the reward, choose how much a customer should spend to earn it, then set the points to match.
Step 2: Points, stamps, tiers or vouchers?
Choose points. Every customer already understands spend, earn and redeem, and the rules fit on one line.
| Design | How it works | What a customer must learn |
|---|---|---|
| Points | Earn in proportion to spend, redeem for a reward | Spend, earn, redeem |
| Stamp cards (more complex) | One stamp per visit or item | Which purchases count, how many stamps, which reward |
| Tiers (more complex) | Levels unlocked by spend or visits | Thresholds, benefits per level, how to keep a level |
| Vouchers and games (more complex) | Coupons, spins, badges | Expiry, conditions, how each mechanic works |
A points program can copy what a stamp card does. A fixed number of points per drink gives the same result as a stamp, and a large order still earns more. See stamp cards vs points for the side-by-side.
The case against complexity is not only opinion. KPMG’s 2019 survey found that most consumers find programs hard to use.
| Measure | Figure | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Agree programs are too hard to join and/or earning rewards is a challenge | 60% | Global, 2019 |
| Enrolled consumers who use programs a few times a month or less | 55% | Global, 2019 |
Source: KPMG consumer survey of over 18,000 consumers in 20 countries, via PR Newswire, released 26 November 2019.
Step 3: What will it cost at your size?
Check the price for today’s shop and for the one you hope to have in two years. Pricing usually takes one of three forms.
- A free plan with a limit. Read the limit. It may be outlets, members, messages or time.
- Per-location pricing. Cheap for one site, and the bill rises with each opening.
- A flat price for unlimited outlets. The same fee at three outlets or thirty.
Watch for per-member fees and per-message fees, which make a quiet launch cheap and a busy year costly. Our cost guide lists what to compare, and the roundup of loyalty apps for small businesses shows how common options price their plans.
Step 4: Test the sign-up on your own phone
Before you buy anything, join the program as a customer would. Count the steps and note where you hesitate.
| Sign-up method | What the customer does | Friction |
|---|---|---|
| App download | Find the app, install it, create an account | High |
| Account form | Type name, phone, email and password | Medium to high |
| QR code and email | Scan, enter an email | Low |
This matters because every extra step is a place to lose a customer. Our guide to loyalty cards with no app download covers the evidence. If the sign-up takes you more than a minute, it will take your customers longer.
Step 5: What must your staff do?
Count the actions at the till. Each extra one slows the queue and invites staff to skip it. The test is to hand a new team member the system and ask them to add points once without help.
Look for these three things:
- It runs on a phone your staff already carry, with no new terminal.
- Adding and redeeming points each take one action.
- A mistake can be corrected on the spot.
Step 6: Launch at the counter and track what happens
Put the QR code where customers wait: beside the card machine, on the counter or on the bill folder. Tell staff to offer it to every customer for the first two weeks. The launch guide for the counter covers signage and the wording staff can use.
Then measure, because that is the only way to answer whether it drives sales. Note your busiest and quietest days before launch. After a few weeks, check three numbers:
- Members signed up.
- Members who came back at least once.
- Members who redeemed a reward.
Redemption deserves attention. In one study of a retailer’s points program, only 3% of purchases had a redemption and 60% of customers never redeemed in 43 months.
| Measure | Figure | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Purchases with a redemption | 3% | One Latin American home and hardware retailer |
| Customers who never redeemed | 60% over 43 months | Same program, 1% of spend earned as points |
Source: Stourm, Bradlow and Fader, Journal of Marketing Research, 2015.
That is one retailer, not every shop. It does show that a program can run for years while most customers never claim a reward. Keep the reward within reach so your members redeem it.
Checklist: compare two or three programs
Score each program 0, 1 or 2 on each check, add the numbers, and drop any option that scores 0 on cost or staff steps.
| Check | 0 points | 1 point | 2 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reward design | Tiers, games or vouchers | Visits or items with points added | Points tied to spend |
| Cost at your size | Per-location or per-member fees | Flat fee with limits | Flat fee, or free for one outlet |
| Customer sign-up | App download | Form | QR code and email |
| Staff steps | New hardware or several steps | Two steps | One action |
| Second outlet | Separate balances | Shared with extra setup | One balance by default |
| Free plan | Time-limited trial | Free with tight limits | Free with no time limit |
What should you ask before you sign up?
- Does the free plan have a time limit, and what does the price become at a second outlet?
- Is there a fee per member, per location or per message?
- Does a customer need an app or a password?
- Does one balance work across every outlet?
- Can I take my customer list with me if I leave?
Where Gimify fits
Gimify is a points-only program that you can start yourself at app.gimify.com/start. The free plan covers one outlet with unlimited members and has no time limit, so you can run the six steps above on real customers before paying. Customers join with a QR code and an email, staff add or redeem points on any phone, and the unlimited-outlets plan is US$99 a month with no per-member or per-location fees.
Questions owners ask
What is the best rewards program for a small business?
The best one is the simplest your customers will use. Points that follow spend, a sign-up with no app, a flat price and a free plan you can test with real customers are the features that matter most for a shop with no IT staff.
How much should a small business rewards program cost?
Start free if you can. Some programs are free for one outlet with no time limit. Before you upgrade, compare a flat monthly fee against per-location and per-member pricing, because those grow as you do.
Do customers need an app to join a rewards program?
Not if you choose carefully. Programs that sign customers up with a QR code and an email avoid the app download that many customers will not make.
How do I know if my rewards program is working?
Track the number of members, how many come back, and how many redeem. Pick a start date, count repeat visits for a few weeks before and after, and judge it on those numbers.
Should a small business use stamps or points?
Points. Customers already understand spend, earn and redeem, and points follow the size of the purchase. Stamps add rules about which purchases count, and the same card cannot reward a large order fairly.
How long does it take to start a rewards program?
The steps are choosing a reward, choosing an earn rate, setting up the program, printing or displaying a QR code and briefing staff. Plan a short staff briefing before the first day.
Read next
Start free
Gimify is free for one outlet with unlimited members and no time limit. Unlimited outlets are one flat monthly price.
Start free See plans